Home care agency interview scorecard: questions to ask
A guide and printable scorecard for phoning or meeting up to three home care agencies, with the questions to ask and what the answers tell you.
Reviewed by Len Burgess, Senior Care Advisor. Last reviewed 10 November 2026. Next review due 10 November 2027.
This page explains our home care agency interview scorecard, a printable sheet to use when you phone or meet home care agencies so you can compare up to three. You can download the printable worksheet as a PDF once you enter your email address.
Download the worksheet
A printable A4 PDF with room to write your answers. It is free: enter your email address and we will send you the link.
Questions to ask a home care agency before you choose
Choosing a home care agency means letting strangers into your home, or your relative's. A home care agency interview scorecard helps you ask every agency the same questions and record the answers, so you can compare fairly rather than going by whichever sounded friendliest on the phone. This page explains what the scorecard covers, for domiciliary care in England. The printable scorecard is a free download as a PDF after you enter your email address.
It is for care at home: agencies, carer visits and live in care. It is not about care homes.
Who should use a home care agency scorecard?
Use it if you are arranging care at home for yourself or a relative, whether you will pay privately, use a personal budget or have the council arrange it. It is most useful when you are speaking to two or three agencies and want a record you can share with the family.
How to use a home care agency interview scorecard
- Check each agency on the Care Quality Commission (CQC) website before you call.
- Ask the same questions of every agency, so the comparison is fair.
- Write notes as you go, and score each section from 0 to 3.
- Add the scores at the end of the sheet and note your gut feeling.
- Agree in writing what you have been told before care starts.
What to ask a home care agency
Is the agency registered with the CQC?
The NHS says all homecare agencies must register with the CQC, and the CQC publishes inspection reports you can read before choosing. Ask for the latest rating and report date, whether there is a registered manager, and anything in the report that needs improvement. Be cautious if an agency cannot explain its report.
Services and flexibility: what care can the agency provide?
Check that the agency offers the care you need, such as personal care, companionship, overnight care, live in care or help with shopping and medicines. Ask the shortest visit length, whether hours can change at short notice and when care could start.
Carers: recruitment, training and continuity
The NHS suggests asking how carers are matched to you, what training they have and whether they have supported people with similar needs. Ask about DBS checks and references, how many different carers might visit in a week, and whether you can ask for a man or woman. Consistency matters, especially for people living with dementia.
Rota and timekeeping: what if the carer is late?
The NHS suggests asking whether visits happen at set times and whether you will be told about delays. Ask how long the time window is, what happens if a carer does not turn up, who covers sickness and holidays, and whether you can see the rota in advance.
Care plans and communication
Ask who writes the care plan, whether you help write it, and when it is reviewed. Ask how visits are recorded, whether family can see the notes, and who your main contact is.
Help with medicines from a home carer
Ask whether carers help with medicines, which tasks they do (reminders, handing out, creams), who is trained and how it is recorded. Ask what happens if a dose is missed or a mistake is made.
Emergencies and out of hours
The NHS suggests asking how to reach the agency in an emergency or out of hours. Ask what carers do if they find someone has fallen or is unwell, what happens in bad weather and what happens if the person goes into hospital.
Home care costs and invoicing
According to the NHS, a reputable agency should give you a clear price list and a monthly bill. Ask for the price per hour or per visit, higher rates for evenings, weekends and bank holidays, extra charges for travel or set up, and how prices can change. Ask what charges are extra. Our guide to paying for home care in England explains how costs and funding work.
Notice, contracts and cancelling home care
The NHS suggests asking if you can read the contract first and, if the council pays, see the council's contract with the agency. Ask how much notice you must give to stop or change care, whether there are cancellation charges, how much notice the agency gives you and how to complain.
Warning signs when choosing a home care agency
Be cautious if an agency is not registered with the CQC or cannot explain its report, cannot give a clear price list or contract, asks for large payments in advance or pushes you to sign quickly, cannot say who will visit or how late visits are handled, or gives vague answers.
Tips for using the home care agency scorecard
- Phone at least two agencies, ideally three.
- Ask the same questions in the same order.
- Write down the name of the person you spoke to.
- Ask for the answers by email, or in writing in the contract.
- Include the person who will receive care in at least one conversation.
- Notice how they make you feel. Did they listen?
- Keep the completed sheet to compare at the first review.
Common questions about choosing a home care agency
How do I check a home care agency is legitimate?
Search for the agency on the CQC website. The NHS says all homecare agencies must register with the CQC, and you can read their inspection reports.
What should a good home care agency provide in writing?
A clear price list, a written contract, a written care plan and a monthly bill. Ask to read the contract before you sign.
What is the difference between a home care agency and employing a carer directly?
With an agency, the agency arranges carers and cover. The NHS says if the council funds your care you can take your personal budget as direct payments to hire someone you know, but you then take on employer responsibilities such as cover for illness and holidays.
How many home care agencies should I speak to?
Speaking to two or three lets you compare answers and prices. The scorecard has space for three.
Related guides and tools
Get the worksheet by email
The worksheet is free. Enter your email address and we will send you the link to the fillable PDF.
Sources
Important information about this document
This worksheet was written by CareAssura from our own knowledge of the care sector and from the public sources listed in this document. It is general information, not advice. It is not a substitute for advice from your council, an independent financial or legal adviser, the NHS or another qualified professional.
Rules, amounts, thresholds and services change, and we may update or withdraw a worksheet at any time without notice. Please check the "last reviewed" date and the listed sources before you rely on anything here. We try to keep our worksheets accurate, but we cannot guarantee that they are complete or up to date. To the extent the law allows, we accept no responsibility for decisions made in reliance on them.
Naming a service, organisation, product or provider is not a recommendation or endorsement. Links to other websites are for convenience, and we are not responsible for their content.