Care home comparison worksheet: compare homes after a visit
A guide and printable worksheet to compare up to four care homes after you have visited, with facts, scores, deal breakers, family votes and next steps.
Reviewed by Len Burgess, Senior Care Advisor. Last reviewed 10 November 2026. Next review due 10 November 2027.
This page explains our care home comparison worksheet, a printable sheet for comparing up to four care homes side by side after you have visited them. You can download the printable worksheet as a PDF once you enter your email address.
Download the worksheet
A printable A4 PDF with room to write your answers. It is free: enter your email address and we will send you the link.
How to compare care homes after a visit
You have toured two, three or four care homes. Each one had something good about it, and now the details are blurring together. A care home comparison worksheet puts the facts, scores and opinions of every home side by side, so the family can decide with a clear head. This page explains what the worksheet covers, for care homes in England. The printable worksheet is a free download as a PDF after you enter your email address.
The comparison worksheet is a second sheet. It follows the care home visit scorecard, which you fill in during each visit. The scorecard records what you saw in one home. The comparison worksheet pulls the homes together so you can choose.
Who should use a care home comparison worksheet?
Use it if you are choosing between several homes for a relative or for yourself, particularly if more than one person has a say. It suits residential care, nursing home and dementia care searches, and it helps families who find that everyone remembers the visits differently.
How to use the care home comparison worksheet
- Write what matters most to the person before you start comparing.
- Fill in the facts from each home's own paperwork and its CQC page, not from memory.
- Score each area from 1 to 5 using your visit notes. Leave a box blank if you did not see it.
- Agree your deal breakers and check each home against them.
- Ask each family member for a first, second and third choice, with reasons.
- Choose a home and a back up, then list the next steps and who does them.
Care home comparison checklist: what to record
Comparing care homes by CQC rating
The Care Quality Commission (CQC) is the independent regulator of care in England. It rates services as Outstanding, Good, Requires improvement or Inadequate. Each home has a CQC page showing its rating and the date of its latest inspection. Record both, and note any concerns or requirements in the report. Ratings can change, so the date matters. The CQC says providers must make their latest report available to you, so ask for it.
Care home fees comparison: what the weekly fee includes
Record the weekly fee quoted, what it includes, what is charged as an extra, whether a top-up fee is needed and the notice period. Ask each home to put these in writing, because the words "fee includes" can mean different things at different homes. For example, laundry, hairdressing and activities may be inside the fee in one home and extra in another. A fair comparison needs the same questions answered by every home.
Type of home: residential care, nursing home or dementia care
The NHS explains that residential homes provide accommodation and personal care, while nursing homes also have qualified nurses on duty. Record the type, because it affects both fees and whether the home can meet the person's needs if they get worse.
Scoring areas when you compare care homes
The worksheet scores areas such as welcome, cleanliness, safety, bedrooms, food, activities, outdoor space, staffing, care for specific needs, management and value for money. Adding up the scores gives a rough ranking. Treat it as a prompt for conversation, not an answer. A home that scores lower overall might still be the best fit for one important need.
Deal breakers when choosing a care home
A deal breaker is something that would rule a home out, whatever its score, such as being too far for regular visits, being unable to meet a specific need or being unaffordable. Agree your deal breakers before you compare, so the decision is fair.
Family votes and choosing together
Ask each family member for a first, second and third choice and a reason. The person's own view comes first if they can give it. Where a family disagrees, voting in the open helps you see why.
Next steps after choosing a care home
Phone the preferred home to check there is a place. Ask for a written contract and read the terms on fees and notice. Check the funding with the council, and ask for a trial stay or a second visit at a different time of day. Speak to the GP about any health needs the home must meet, and tell the other homes your decision.
Questions to ask when choosing between care homes
If two homes look similar on paper, ask what would make the person have to leave, how many agency staff are used, how often fees rise and how complaints are handled. Also ask how the home would support the person if their needs grow. Our care home visit scorecard has a full question list.
What is a top-up fee in a care home?
A top-up is extra money paid by the family when the person chooses a home that costs more than the council would normally pay. The NHS says a placement may end if the family stops paying. Ask the council before you agree to one.
Tips for comparing care homes
- Fill in the facts from paperwork, not from memory.
- Compare the same things for every home.
- Do not compare more than four homes at once.
- Revisit your top two at a different time of day.
- Read the contract before the final decision.
- Check the funding early, because it affects what is realistic.
- Write down why you chose, and review the decision after the first weeks.
Common questions about comparing care homes
How many care homes should I compare?
Comparing at least two or three is sensible. The worksheet has space for up to four, which is usually enough to see real differences without becoming overwhelming.
What should I compare when choosing a care home?
Compare the CQC rating and inspection date, the weekly fee and what it includes, extras, notice periods, distance for visitors, and how well each home can meet the person's needs, plus your visit scores.
What is a deal breaker when choosing a care home?
It is something that rules a home out whatever its score, such as an unmet care need or a fee you cannot afford.
How do I check a care home's CQC rating?
Search for the home on the CQC website. Its page shows the rating and the date of the latest inspection, and you can read the full report.
Related guides and tools
Get the worksheet by email
The worksheet is free. Enter your email address and we will send you the link to the fillable PDF.
Sources
Important information about this document
This worksheet was written by CareAssura from our own knowledge of the care sector and from the public sources listed in this document. It is general information, not advice. It is not a substitute for advice from your council, an independent financial or legal adviser, the NHS or another qualified professional.
Rules, amounts, thresholds and services change, and we may update or withdraw a worksheet at any time without notice. Please check the "last reviewed" date and the listed sources before you rely on anything here. We try to keep our worksheets accurate, but we cannot guarantee that they are complete or up to date. To the extent the law allows, we accept no responsibility for decisions made in reliance on them.
Naming a service, organisation, product or provider is not a recommendation or endorsement. Links to other websites are for convenience, and we are not responsible for their content.